Why Artists Keep Returning to Mythology

A vast range of creatives are turning to antiquity for inspiration, rediscovering ancient myths and harnessing their potent narratives in response to our turbulent times.

Antiquity is in. References to classical mythology abound across every corner of the art world. Last month, a number of Met Gala guests turned up in Hellenistic-inspired looks. Anne Hathaway wore a Michael Kors dress hand-painted by Peter McGough in the style of a Grecian urn, the Greek goddess of peace front and centre. Venus de Milo appeared as a Schiaparelli gown worn by Kylie Jenner, and again that same week in a striking sequence from Rosalia’s LUX tour in London, in which the singer was transformed into a living sculpture with the aid of light, shadow and a dozen white-gloved back-up dancers. Then, next month, Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey arrives in theaters, the first major film adaptation of a Greek myth in a generation.

Time and time again, Greek mythology has found a way to revive itself – proof, if any were needed, that these stories are more than dusty fantasies of a long-dead antiquity. Somehow, these myths have withstood the tests of time. They persistently captivate the human imagination across millennia and, for whatever reason, prove ever-fertile ground to revisit.

For Frits Scholten, head of sculpture at the Rijksmuseum and curator of its recent exhibition, Metamorphoses, these stories tap into something eternal in us. Ovid’s Metamorphoses, famously christened “the Bible of artists” by painter Karel van Mander in 1604, is an astonishing, 15-book Latin poem of the greatest Greek myths. “Ovid is so universal,” says Scholten. “He describes very human feelings and sensibilities: love, death, violence, jealousy, you name it.” 

The exhibition, set to continue at the Galleria Borghese in Rome from June 23, traces the long romance with classical myth from the Renaissance to now. Under one gallery, Narcissus (ca. 1597–1598) by Baroque master Caravaggio is juxtaposed with Cornelius Postma’s own surrealist rendition, while Gian Lorenzo Bernini’s Sleeping Hermaphroditus (1620), on loan from the Musée du Louvre, is paired with Auguste Rodin’s sculpture of the goddess of love in Pygmalion and Galatea (1908–9).

Scholten himself was surprised by how topical the show turned out to be: “I never expected so many contemporary artists to be interested in his stories,” he admits. The exhibition is, above all, proof that each generation finds its way into the text. “There’s a constant dialogue,” says Scholten, “but each generation takes from it what it likes most, or can use best.” Take Medusa: once the emblem of the monstrous, then a glossy logo for Versace, now a banner of the anti-femicide movement, she has been endlessly reimagined and imbued with new meaning. 

Gian Lorenzo Bernini's Sleeping Hermaphroditus (1620). Photograph Courtesy of Rijksmuseum/Amie Galbraith

Some 75 kilometres from the Borghese, another ode to Ovid will soon unfold. Publishing project Sendb00ks is set to host a two-week artist residency at Rocca Sinibalda, an Italian fortress-palace dubbed the “Castle of Metamorphoses.” Home to dozens of Renaissance frescoes teeming with Ovidian characters – Narcissus, Europa and the Bull, Medusa – the site is charged with mythological symbolism. For founder Gemma Janes, the appeal lies precisely in this imagery’s refusal to die. “This theme of transformation might be at the heart of all creativity,” she says, “ this need or desire to capture a fleeting state.” Artists invited to the castle won’t have to dig into a sequestered past to reinterpret the myth: it bleeds through the walls. It is perhaps for this reason it has repeatedly seduced the elites of the art and literary world, from Allen Ginsberg to Peggy Guggenheim and Martin Amis. 

The resurgence of classicism is at once cyclical and inevitable, the residency’s art director Rana Tabatabaie points out. Yet she links its current popularity to a specific antagonist. “The revival of classical visuals can be partly seen as a psychological reaction against the frictionless world of AI,” Tabatabaie suggests. Classicism, for her, is “fundamentally humanist” and serves as a “powerful form of raw, layered, and weighted storytelling.” This makes for the exact kind of anchor one reaches for in the midst of an era she describes as intent on “smoothing out the rawness and imperfections humans naturally desire.” 

Fresco depicting the abduction of Persephone in the Castle of Rocca Sinibalda. Courtesy of Bianca Pozzi/Castello di Rocca Sinibalda

Much of classical mythology’s longevity comes down to its visual potency. The ancient Greeks worked with a boundless repertoire of gods, heroes and monsters, turning them into images both vivid and lasting. “Every generation has inherited visual cues from the previous generations,” says Dr Evelien Bracke, classicist at Maynooth and Ghent University and author of The Meaning of Myth in Uncertain Times: How Classical Mythology Helps Us Navigate a World in Crisis. This archetypal shorthand is instantly recognisable, from ancient mosaics to Renaissance paintings to contemporary art, and it is this legibility that ensures its cultural continuity. “Myths allow successive generations to project their own concerns onto them, which then translates into art,” Bracke adds. 

Bracke considers the contemporary context from another angle: The internet, she argues, now works as a “megaphone of mythology,” letting myths “travel faster, further and with more emotional charge.” The threshold for engagement is lowered and the room for reinterpretation expands. “Humans are storytellers by nature,” she says, “and it does feel that a lot of people today are in search of meaning in their lives. Especially with the acceleration of technology, worsening of the mental health crisis and human disconnect, ancient stories can provide us with a compass and a way to connect with our past as human storytellers.” Janes puts it more plainly: “In moments of rapid change, people reach for tradition, or the past, as a way to keep balance.” Antiquity feels like a fixed point of reference to return to while the cultural landscape evolves at a dizzying pace, and becomes increasingly untethered from time and place. Age also connotes authority, Scholten notes: “For some reason, we believe what was written 2000 years ago; it must be right because it’s endured all these ages, all these centuries,” he says. “In such a way, you could maybe even compare it to the Bible.”

Scholten does not mean to suggest that mythology has replaced religion. Yet he does acknowledge its role in reconnecting us to the natural world – a role that Christianity once played. “In Ovid, you can find an awareness of the preciousness of our world and our cosmos,” he says. “Everything is animated; everything can contain a soul, and everything is connected to the divine.” 

Caravaggio, Narcissus (ca. 1597–1598) Palazzo Barberini, Rome. Courtesy of Rijksmuseum.

Perhaps the greatest allure of myth is that it helps us deal with the complexity and ambiguity of our existence while allowing us to maintain a comfortable distance. Natalie Haynes, classicist, novelist, and host of BBC Radio 4’s Natalie Haynes Stands Up for the Classics, admits she will forever return to these stories “until the world is less dystopian.” Finding it increasingly difficult to digest the news, as depressing as it is, she seeks solace in the Greeks: “there’s always so much to explore intellectually, emotionally and psychologically, but I never find it oppressive,” she says. 

This is, it seems, the crux of mythology’s influence: to access intimate human experiences – love, danger, deception – but always at arm’s length. 

Is this a genuine resurgence in mythology, or just another generation telling itself the classics are back? Haynes refuses to oversell it. “Every generation rediscovers classics for themselves,” she hedges. “Ask me again in 10 years if the bubble’s burst.” What’s undeniable is that mythology persists even in an era of immense flux and change. Its ability to adapt to any context without losing its potency is what will carry them on for years to come. Scholten at least finds comfort in “knowing that these things do not die — they come back.” Ovid’s line in book XV is, in the end, the truest description of mythology itself: “all things change; nothing is extinguished.”

Metamorphoses runs at the Galleria Borghese, Rome, from 23 June until 20 September.