Keira Knightley: She Did It Her Way
From the 'Pirates of the Caribbean' phenomenon to 'Black Doves,' the actor talks about fame, privacy and choosing roles she’s genuinely drawn to.
Photography by Alasdair McLellan
When a teenage Keira Knightley landed a role in a film inspired by a Disneyland ride, she thought it would probably flop. Yet Pirates of the Caribbean became a global phenomenon, and Knightley was, all of a sudden, unimaginably famous.
The year was 2003. Knightley was 18. She was a very beautiful, very young woman suddenly at the mercy of the intense misogyny that characterized the ’00s press circus. She immediately felt uncomfortable with that level of attention: “As soon as it happened I was very, ‘Oh shit, oh shit, I can’t handle this,’” she tells me.
Knightley decided to step away from all that as much as she could. She avoided enormous blockbusters and took roles “selfishly,” playing characters who interested her. Two decades later, the cruelty and intensity of that press era is the subject of a cultural reckoning – even if, Knightley suspects, the underlying misogyny has found a new home on social media.
Meanwhile, by following her instincts, the 40-year-old actor has built an impressively varied and sustained career, with two Oscar nominations. Knightley still works on her own terms, with a recent turn to entertaining, funny roles, including the Netflix show Black Doves. And alongside her acting work, she has been an ambassador for Chanel since 2007. As social media has become ubiquitous, the early lessons she learned about fame, which helped her maintain her sense of self, feel more prescient than ever.

There are certain scenes and costumes from your films that have become enduring style moments. I’m thinking of the hairband and midriff in Bend It Like Beckham, the Atonement green dress, the Love Actually hat moment. Can you tell when these moments are going to resonate in such a dramatic way?
KEIRA KNIGHTLEY The green dress in Atonement was really designed that way. It was meant to be “the dress.” But with, say, Bend It Like Beckham… I mean, I had a really good stomach when I was 16. [Laughs] So, I felt like: let’s get that out as much as possible. Also, all this was just what we were wearing at the time. The hat – Britney Spears also wore that kind of hat a lot. That was very early ’00s fashion.
In my research, I came across photos of those low-rise jeans.
KK Oh, the low-rise jeans, yes! The older fashion crowd would 100 percent take the piss out of you at the time. It was considered very teenage.
Some of these looks have come back among Gen Z. Do you ever see people on the street and think, “Oh my God, that’s my hat”?
KK I was on the tube the other day. What I actually thought was: “I wore all of that. She has better nails and more makeup, but apart from that, it’s like looking at myself on the tube at 17. Very bizarre.” It was great.
Early in your career, because you were so young, beautiful and talented, you were hounded by the press. At the time, I was too young to understand that as a large-scale bullying event, but now I’d see it that way. In that era, it seemed like the unquestioned way in which very beautiful young women were treated. A few books are out now examining ’00s culture, but I wonder if you feel that the way young women in the public eye are treated has meaningfully changed.
KK I don’t know because I’m not that age anymore. And older women weren’t treated like that at the time. It was very specifically aimed at very young women who couldn’t afford to go after the press legally, right? I think that was a big part of it. And I’m not sure it has changed – it’s probably still there. I’m not on social media, but I don’t hear that people are particularly nice on it. So, I suspect that’s the new version of the old treatment.
I read in an interview from some time ago that you took a year off acting when you were in your early 20s, because of the flurry around you. What did you do in that year?
KK I went traveling.
Where did you go?
KK I spent four or five months in Paris, learning French, taking a French course. I went to Bali and all around Indonesia. And then I did a bit of interrailing – I took the train all over Europe. I did bits and pieces.
I like how strong-willed that is. It makes me think of my favorite film of yours, Never Let Me Go, adapted from Kazuo Ishiguro’s book. I must have watched it 10 times the year it came out on DVD.
KK It was so interesting because it didn’t do well at all when it came out, and it didn’t get particularly well reviewed. But then it came out on DVD and got re-reviewed, and it got really good reviews. And you’re like, “Fucking hell, guys.” [Laughs]
It’s such a chilling, spiky film.
KK It’s fucking horrible. [Laughs] Have you read the book?
I did, and I loved it. In the film, I loved how wicked your character was. I didn’t understand this when I first watched it, but in hindsight, it made me think of your press treatment. The paparazzi made you look like a very aloof woman. That’s obviously one of the big misogynistic tropes: the cold woman. In that context, I love that you chose to do a character like this. Sometimes, when a woman has been put into a box, she’s like, “Okay, I have to prove everyone wrong. I have to take on roles where I’m the girl next door. I’m not going to play into that.” But you did the opposite. Was that what you were thinking?
KK I hear you, but no, that wasn’t why. I’ve always been incredibly selfish about the characters I’ve played. It hasn’t been about a public perception of me at all because I can’t do things that way. I have to go with what interests me. I’d read the book and been like, “What the fuck?” And also, she’s such a jealous creature, and so human. She has best friends whom she loves so much that she must destroy them.
And there’s her desire to be loved.
KK Yes, she’s desperate. It all comes from that, doesn’t it? From this desperate desire to be loved and her inability to connect, so she has to destroy everyone around her. It’s horrible. [Laughs] And it’s very human. I hope you don’t know it on that level, but everyone knows jealousy, right? And you know it’s toxic. I thought that was so interesting. But when it came out, nobody understood. People didn’t understand why they didn’t run away. But that’s the point: we don’t run. None of us do.
You really blew up with Pirates of the Caribbean. Did you have any concept of how monumental those films would be when you got that role?
KK No, at that point it was a joke. It was based on a Disney theme-park ride – everyone thought it was going to be awful. And no pirate film had worked in 40 years. I still thought it was fucking extraordinary that I got it, and it was with Johnny Depp, which instantly made it cooler. His character was written as totally straight, so he completely developed and devised that whole thing that went into it. But no, nobody thought it was going to do very much. I don’t think even Disney did at the time. It was an old ride. And then it obviously took on a whole life of its own.
Around the time you were nominated for an Oscar for Pride and Prejudice, Pirates 2 was getting bad reviews. Most people that young don’t have a strong sense of what to listen to and what to filter out. How did the whiplash feel?
KK Not great. [Laughs] I was very young and didn’t know how to filter anything out. It was so extreme in both directions – I was the best thing ever or the worst ever. So, it was very tricky to navigate. And a public persona takes on a life of its own – it doesn’t necessarily have much to do with the person. You’re just an image, right? Just the character you play. It’s not who you are – you’re very separate from that.
But when you’re still “becoming,” which you are as a teenager and in your early 20s, it’s tricky to navigate when you have other people’s projections of what you are forced onto you. Knowing where you actually sit within all that is a very strange thing to get your head around.

I feel that you could have chosen a career that was all huge-budget films, but you chose otherwise.
KK I definitely swerved away from that. That was very purposeful. I couldn’t take the fame that went with it. It wasn’t a lifestyle I wanted. I really like going on the tube. I’m probably the only person in London who really appreciates the Northern line. I was lucky to have been given an opportunity to experience an extraordinary level of success and to be in a !lm of that size – it totally set up my career. And it was amazing. I wouldn’t change it, but I also didn’t want to live in that kind of fishbowl. I knew that very clearly, as soon as it happened. I was very, “Oh shit, oh shit, I can’t handle this!” [Laughs]
I imagine most people would have taken a long time to decide it wasn’t for them.
KK Well, it was over a five-year period. So, it did take me some time. But it’s also because I’m very selfish in taking on characters. Those big films weren’t the sort I watched. I did when I was a kid, but later they weren’t what I was watching and what I was interested in doing. So, I thought that since I had the opportunity, I wanted to try and steer toward characters I was really interested in playing. Added to that, I couldn’t handle that level of fame. It also didn’t feel true to me.
What were your favorite subjects in school?
KK History, English…
You’re not a curveball STEM person?
KK I fucking wish I were a curveball STEM person. No. Maths made no sense to me at all. Physics, chemistry – no sense at all. I liked biology. I could understand that. I was like, “Yes, cut something open. Look at it.” I get that. How a leaf works – I get that. But fucking physics? No.
Do your kids have the same intellectual interests you did?
KK They’re definitely not into maths. [Laughs] We’re definitely not a maths family. Stories are big, yeah.

You’ve been with your partner, the musician James Righton, for a long time, in celebrity years.
KK Hundreds of celebrity years.
Why do you think you’ve been together for such a long time?
KK God. Why have we been together? We don’t want to break up. It’s as simple as that. Yes, we annoy each other. We argue, but fuck me, do we laugh! And I suppose that’s the key to everything.
I was a big fan of his group, the Klaxons, back in the day. I was listening to a podcast recently with the frontman, Jamie Reynolds, and it brought that whole era back.
KK They knew how to have fun. It was all very, very fun. There was definitely a dark side. But very fun.
That’s something I think Gen Z misses a little: that era’s sense of fun.
KK You’re always being watched now. You can’t have fun when you’re being watched. Having been followed by paparazzi, as I was, I know you can’t have fun when you’re being watched. Yes, you need to not be watched to dance. You need to not be watched to let yourself go.
Did you see the artist Jeremy Deller’s project about dance music a couple of years ago? He went into classrooms, spoke to young people and showed them footage of people dancing before everyone had smartphones. And they were all like, “Oh my God, I can’t imagine embarrassing myself like that.”
KK It’s so great to embarrass yourself like that. I had a night out – it was for Chanel. We were in Lake Como, and there was an after-party, and everyone put their phones away and danced, and it was sweaty and silly and ridiculous and totally great. I hadn’t done it for about 10 years, and you suddenly go, “My God!” There’s something animalistic in your body; the release of whatever it is that gets released when you move your body in a stupid way to music is just one of the great pleasures of life.

Speaking of pleasures: I loved Black Doves. It was perfect Christmas viewing. What do you gravitate toward in a role now, at this stage in your career?
KK Who knows how I will feel next year, but this year I really want entertainment. That’s why I loved Black Doves – it was silly and fun. And it’s got a melancholia to it, a loneliness that makes it interesting. And yes, ultimately it’s a piece of entertainment. I’ve got a film coming out in October, The Woman in Cabin 10, which is also entertainment. It’s not meant to be Proust – it’s just meant to be enjoyable.
Maybe it’s the way the world is at the moment, but I don’t want to go down the really dark path. I want to go down the entertainment path right now. And I’m doing Black Doves, season two. We start in September. So, again, there’s enough darkness in it, but ultimately the idea is that it should be entertainment.
That isn’t how I’ve always been. And maybe I won’t be like that next year or the year after, but right now, I think, “What do I want to watch?” I want to watch something silly that I enjoy for the sake of it.
How is that different from what you used to look for in a role?
KK Again, it’s constantly changing. But I’ve been offered a couple of things recently that 10 years ago I would have said yes to in a heartbeat. Like, super serious, super interesting, very complicated. And I just went, “Oh, I can’t look at that right now.”
So, it’s a gut-level reaction.
KK It’s 100 percent gut level. I really wish it were slightly less gut level.
This article was published in September 2025 in Mastermind 18. Purchase the issue here.
Fashion by Conor Manning. Hair by Luke Hersheson. Makeup by Georgina Graham. Manicure by Sabrina Gayle. Production by Partner Films.
