The AI Revolution in Hollywood: Innovation or Infiltration?

From voice synthesis to AI-generated visuals, the use of artificial intelligence in 'The Brutalist' and 'Emilia Pérez' has ignited a fierce debate about the future of film authenticity and ethics.

In the run-up to the 2025 Oscars, an artificial intelligence controversy permeated the press. Dávid Jancsó, the editor of one of the night’s biggest contenders, The Brutalist,  revealed in an interview with tech magazine RedShark that intelligence-driven speech synthesis software Respeecher had been used to improve certain spoken passages in Hungarian. Jancsó also revealed that GenAI was used at the end of the film “to conjure a series of architectural drawings and finished buildings in the style of the fictional architect.” 

Responding to backlash, director Brady Corbet explained the technology was never used to alter the actors’ performances in English; however, by tweaking certain sounds and vowels, it allowed passages in Hungarian to sound as authentic as possible. 

As it turned out, The Brutalist’s team were not the only crew to resort to AI. Emilia Pérez sound mixer Cyril Holtz also used the Respeecher technology to enhance the singing of Karla Sofía Gascón, blending  her voice with that of songwriter and composer Camille. Pablo Larraín’s biopic on opera singer Maria Callas, Maria, used another AI tool, Audioshake, to mix Angelina Jolie’s singing with Callas’ voice from 1960s recordings.

These revelations began a fascinating debate on the role and ethics of AI in film. What’s acceptable in our use of this technology? Can an actor’s performance still be considered authentic if finessed with the help of AI? And what guardrails need to be set up, if any? In the domain of visual special effects, it seems acceptable that AI would accelerate a technical process that would otherwise be more time-consuming, with effects such as stunt-replacing shots (like James Mangold’s motorcycle shots in A Complete Unknown) or adding contemporary actors into old footage (such as in Baz Luhrmann’s Elvis), without actually affecting or enhancing a creative performance. However, it has clearly become increasingly difficult to tell what has or hasn’t been manipulated by the technology.

Selena Gomez in 'Emilia Perez'. Image courtesy of Pathé. All rights reserved.

Historically, the craft of filmmaking has evolved in tandem with the evolution of technology. The birth of film came simultaneously with the creation of special effects, when filmmakers like George Méliès blended film and illusion in films such as A Trip to the Moon (1902), using basic camera tricks including stop motion, slow motion, dissolve, fade-out, superimposition and double exposure. 

Brett Halperin, a University of Washington doctoral student in human-centered design and engineering, interviewed picketing film workers about AI during the 2023 strikes. Halperin offered a nuanced perspective on the topic in an interview with UWNews by explaining that “the death of cinema trope resurfaced with each major technological shift.” Whether it was the arrival of sound in film in 1926, the rise of color, television or digital media, massive disruption emerged, but this also created new professions. Halperin believes that AI presents “another iteration of this trope that continues to reflect the shifting cultural and industrial anxieties about technological agency.” However, he continues, “part of what makes cinema unique to other art forms is that it has always depended on complex, evolving technologies.”

Angelina Jolie in 'Maria.' Image courtesy of Netflix.

It seems the greatest risk in using AI technologies is the suppression of jobs by replacing man-made work with machines. However, on the LA Times podcast The Envelope, Corbet suggested that by working with Respeecher, a Ukrainian software company based in Kiev, they did not cancel jobs, but actually hired engineers to work “manually” on the process. Corbet also made clear that Adrian Brody and Felicity Jones owned “their vocal models in perpetuity,” in regards to future copyright infringement risks, referencing other fears around the question of deepfakes, a clear threat to actors. 

The debate on AI didn’t stop Brody from receiving the Academy Award for Best Actor this year, however Variety announced the Academy’s executive committees were investigating how AI will be used in each branch of the industry. These are expected to be published in April.

Hollywood’s AI anxieties have caught public attention several times in the past few years. In May 2024, Scarlett Johansson fought a legal battle against OpenAI’s CEO Sam Altman, who had to halt the use of one of its synthetic ChatGPT voices called Sky, which sounded ”eerily similar” to Johansson’s voice in Spike Jonze’s film Her. Johansson had earlier declined Altman’s offer to use her voice. 

During the promotion of his 2023 film Oppenheimer, director Christopher Nolan gave his view on the burgeoning technology to Wired Magazine explaining that he felt AI could still be “a very powerful tool,” but only if the limits and possibilities are clearly delineated. “If we accord AI the status of a human being, the way at some point legally we did with corporations, then yes, we’re going to have huge problems,” he said.  

Timothée Chalamet as Bob Dylan in 'A Complete Unknown.' © 2025 Searchlight Pictures. All rights reserved.

As the film industry reflects on its environmental impact, the notion of ’green filmmaking’ is taking off, bringing environmental ethical questions about AI, including the reduction of carbon footprints in the making of films, into focus. Last June a study on the expected growth of data centers in America by Goldman Sachs found “the proliferation of AI technology, and the data centers necessary to feed it will drive a surge in power demand, the likes of which hasn’t been seen in a generation,” certain to affect climate change in the years to come. 

Screenwriters are among the most threatened professionals in the industry today with regards to AI. In December 2024, The Atlantic confirmed that tech companies had looted more than 53,000 movies and 85,000 TV episodes of studios’ intellectual property using the website opensubtitles.org, a vast quantity of works created by generations of screenwriters to train their AI systems. The Writer’s Guild rapidly issued a statement asking studios to file charges against AI tech companies. “Having amassed billions in capital on this foundation of wholesale theft, these tech companies now seek to sell back to the studios highly-priced services that plagiarize stolen works created by WGA members and Hollywood labor,” it read 

If tech moguls assume that scripts, songs, articles and books will soon be written at lower costs by AI, a sad world awaits us, in which algorithms continually attempt to simulate the human experience, while never quite succeeding in becoming the real, imperfect, living thing. It’s worth reflecting on the wisdom of Nick Cave, who wrote an open letter on the subject of ChatGPT in January 2023. “Songs arise out of suffering, by which I mean they are predicated upon the complex, internal human struggle of creation and, well, as far as I know, algorithms don’t feel. Data doesn’t suffer. ChatGPT has no inner being, it has been nowhere, it has endured nothing, it has not had the audacity to reach beyond its limitations, and hence it doesn’t have the capacity for a shared transcendent experience, as it has no limitations from which to transcend.”