The Witch, A Symbol of Female Defiance and Resistance

Mona Chollet, the journalist and author of 'In Defence of Witches,' explains the link between witches of the past and modern-day misogyny.

What place did the witch once hold in society?

MC The figure of the witch has been around since antiquity. Any female behavior that was disapproved of was labeled witchcraft. Looking at history, I have seen how unbearable it was to be a woman and to want to live by oneself – that is, to be a woman who puts herself first and whose existence doesn’t depend on a man or a child. In my book I concentrated on the Renaissance, especially the 16th and 17th centuries, during which most of the trials and executions took place. The repression increased gradually. Healers were women whose activity had been tolerated for a very long time when, all of a sudden, the independence of women began to be seen as a threat. Their discoveries were stolen, and they were accused of being dirty and demonic and of having made a pact with the devil.

Apart from the healers, what kinds of women were targeted?

MC Any woman whose behavior seemed suspicious or disturbed the social order. It could be an elderly neighbor who was a little strange, or a woman who was a little too young, too free, and too beautiful. Potentially, any woman. We have to wonder what effect these witch hunts have had on the evolution of society and on women; how they must have inhibited women’s behavior. Try to imagine what it was like to live with that threat hanging over you. From the moment the accusation was made, you could not escape it. Everything was held against you. The witch hunts were an explosion of misogyny. It was as if they applied this label to everything that was intolerable about women.

You say that contemporary societies have not yet realized the full impact and repercussions of this moment of hatred.

MC It seems to me that it must have left deep traces, both in our minds and in the representation of the female body. At the time of the witch hunts, mistrust toward women took hold as misogynistic ideas spread, especially through religion. No social class was spared. I think it still has an effect on the female image: The formation of standards of beauty in relation to the female body. Anything that signifies uncontrollable nature becomes ugly and suspicious. Older women are still very much affected by these hateful images. As a result, growing old is especially difficult for women. I have been told that I go too far here, that aging is hard for men, too. What interests me is the social view of aging.

Sorcery is a reaction to powerful men who are caricatures of misogynistic oppressors and who are proud of it. Mona Chollet

You quote the writer Virginie Despentes, who said, ‘Men have no bodies.’ The dominant sex does not have bodies?

MC A man is not judged on his body, and he can quite easily make judgments about women’s bodies without it reflecting on him. Society’s view of the two is completely different. I was particularly interested in the example of white hair. It’s clear that there is a double standard, that the perception is based on gender. In a man, it is a sign of maturity that makes him more seductive. Maturity and experience are valued in men but are frightening in women. We still have the idea that to be seductive, a woman must seem harmless and naïve. I think a woman who accepts her experience and age is perceived as a threat.

In your book, one of the contemporary images of the witch is the childless woman. Is it still taboo to say that you don’t want a child?

MC It’s more accepted in the United States, where there is a multiplicity of voices expressing themselves on the subject: Both men and women, homosexual and heterosexual. In France, we have a very high birth rate, so any expression on the subject is sketchy and perhaps defensive. We seem to cling to the myth of a female nature that is maternal and necessarily implies the desire for a child. It’s as if we cannot imagine that individuals might have very different desires, and that some may have no desire to procreate.

Is this their way of questioning the social order?

MC Motherhood is hardly ever questioned. We grow up, we find a partner, we have children – that’s something that is rarely questioned. Sometimes people have children just to be left alone, to be in the norm. I discovered that we still walk a narrow line – there are still few opportunities for deviating from the norm. There is a kind of policing of images, either very positive – the ideal mother, the perfect homemaker – or very negative. And these images are produced without reflection. Ideological images are found on Instagram and in magazines and are perpetuated by comments made in everyday life. There is a kind of competition for the embodiment of the ideal woman, which is still very lucrative. Women who are successful at it make great profits.

How do you explain the resurgence of the witch today?

MC There are several reasons. The young people who are talking about witchcraft today seem to want to go back to nature, but don’t want to be identified with a reactionary movement. They don’t want to accept a supposed feminine nature, but they still claim a link to nature that is due to them and that they want to restore. I think there is also a relationship to power. That really strikes me with Donald Trump. There are witches who gather regularly to cast spells on Trump and on Brett Kavanaugh since he was elected to the U.S. Supreme Court. Sorcery is a reaction to powerful men who are caricatures of misogynistic oppressors and who are proud of it. Brazil recently joined the club. These rich white men have no problem saying they want to crush everything that is not white and male. The return of the witch is an expression of resistance, a claim of strength on the part of the oppressed.

Your book is also optimistic and tries to point to another way, far from the dominant norms. You quote Susan Sontag: ‘Women have another option. They can aspire to be wise, not merely nice; to be competent, not merely helpful.’ Does your book give women courage?

MC Yes, that was important to me. Otherwise, it would have been a depressing book. I wanted to bring together examples of women who have already asserted their identity and can help create new role models. I’m banking on a viral effect. The book can be one of the springboards for the struggle, which may help improve relations between men and women.

This is an excerpt from Mastermind 05  published in 2019 – buy all issues here.